Press ALT + F8 to see a list of keyboard shortcuts

Discussion board 13.5: Think & Share 💡Leading Beyond AI Implementation

All Sections
6 unread replies. 6 replies.
  1.  Module 13: Introduction and Instructions (Completed)
  2.  Video 1 [04:06]: Module Introduction (Completed)
  3.  Video 2 [01:58]: Three Roles in Leadership (Completed)
  4.  Video 3 [03:04]: Role 1: Leading as an Orchestrator (Completed)
  5.  Reading: Orchestrating End-to-End Workflows (Completed)
  6.  Video 4 [03:28]: Role 2: Designing as an Architect (Completed)
  7.  Reading: Designing Decision Systems (Completed)
  8.  Self-Study Quiz 13.1: Think & Apply💡 Leading in the Age of AI ((Must submit the Quiz))
  9.  Video 5 [04:17]: Role 3: Building Trust as a Steward (Completed)
  10.  Self-Study Assignment 13.2: Think & Act💡 Leadership Role Diagnostic: Becoming an Orchestrator, Architect and Steward (Completed)
  11.  Video 6 [04:41] Aligning Systems: Workflows, Decisions and Incentives (Completed)
  12.  Video 7 [03:15]: How Three Leadership Roles Work Together (Completed)
  13.  Video 8 [04:54]: Real-World Scenario: All Three Roles in Action (Completed)
  14.  Self-Study Quiz 13.3: Think & Apply💡 Organisational Leadership in the AI Era ((Must submit the Quiz))
  15.  Video 9 [02:37]: Roadmap for Transformation (Completed)
  16.  Video 10 [02:55]: Final Thoughts (Completed)
  17.  Self-Study Assignment 13.4: Think & Act💡 My Leadership Shift in the AI Era (Completed)
  18.  Reading: Leadership Dependency Challenge (Completed)
  19.  Discussion board 13.5: Think & Share 💡Leading Beyond AI Implementation ((Not yet completed))
  20.  Summary and Video Transcripts: Module 13⭐ (Completed)
  21.  Professor Alvin's Recommendation for Further Learning: Module 13 (Completed)
  22.  Module 13: Q&A Discussion Board ((Not yet completed))
  23.  Module 13: Feedback Survey ((Must submit the Quiz))

Module Outcomes.pngLearning Outcomes Addressed: 

  • Explain how the Orchestrator, Architect and Steward roles enable coordination between humans and AI systems.
  • Describe how the interaction between the three leadership roles strengthens organisational performance and governance.
  • Identify shifts in leadership responsibilities from execution oversight to system and workflow design.

Scenario

Throughout this module, you've explored how effective AI transformation depends not just on technology, but on leaders who can orchestrate people and AI, redesign systems, and build trust through responsible governance.

Now, reflect on your own organisation—or one you are familiar with—and share your perspective with your peers.

Respond to the following questions:

  • Which of the three leadership roles—Orchestrator, Architect or Steward—do you believe requires the greatest transformation in your organisation? Explain your reasoning using examples where appropriate.
  • What challenges or organisational barriers might prevent leaders from moving from managing day-to-day execution to leading "above the loop"?
  • How can leaders encourage AI-driven innovation while ensuring accountability, governance and employee trust are maintained?

We also encourage you to go through your peers' responses and share your views.

Estimated Duration: 30 minutes

NOTE: This is a practice activity and will not be graded or impact your programme completion. However, we strongly encourage participation for a more holistic learning experience.

Filter replies by unread    
Reply to Discussion board 13.5: Think & Share 💡Leading Beyond AI Implementation
Cancel
  • Collapse Subdiscussion Hadrian

    In the context of FMCG industry, the biggest requirement to transform should be happened for the role of Architect, for the following reason: 

    • While the workflow has been build on the fundamental of "prepare", "make" and "distribution" - each function within the process are design for their own objective. There will be manual process in between to connect. For example, S&OP process, when the business identify the recent growth and forecast for SKU A to grow further, there will be a debate from supply chain on how to maximize the production capacity and bring efficiency to overall make process, on the other hand, raw material/packaging material will need to review their readiness of higher supply needed. On the other hand, at the lower funnel, sales team will need to bring adjustment into their promo calendar and possibility to include this SKU A or to shift support to this SKU A. A designed that enable AI to play its workflow across Prepare-Make-Sell is needed
    • Human agility can be another barriers, given that all leaders and team set up has been in the company for a long time and some will have some agility to shift into working with new workflow, but bigger portion will resist. There will be a shift of mindset and followed by behavior, but the most critical part is the iteration process as the AI workflow implemented, need to work in parallel across different functions.

    For the 2nd questions, things that limit the movement from day-to-day execution into leading above the loop, will be:

    • Lack of trust for the system that collaboration with AI, while people - esp. in FMCG - has been very hands-on to execute the projects. To grow the brand, is like growing a baby for a brand manager, the process has been managed end-to-end, execute flawlessly and ensuring the brand equity equally growing strong together with sales. To be above the loop can be perceived rudderless, un-controllable if anything goes wrong. 
    • Flawless execution is a sign of achievement, this is a mindset that has been build throughout the career.

    To encourage AI-driven innovation while ensuring accountability, governance and employee trust, leaders can do:

    • Encourage experimentation with AI innovation, through maximizing around area that has smaller commercial risk to business, embrace failure as learning to be shared.
    • Mindset shift to out come for the business, instead of only performance KPI
    Reply to Comment (1 like)
    Cancel
    • Collapse Subdiscussion Priya Jha
      • Which of the three leadership roles—Orchestrator, Architect or Steward—do you believe requires the greatest transformation in your organisation? Explain your reasoning using examples where appropriate.

      Coming from a FinTech Environment, I belive these organizations are already reasonably good at coordination and governance because of project managers, technology leaders, risk functions and established approval processes. The major issue I see is that many workflows were designed around humans. So redesigning and applying systems thinking according to me requires greatest transformation. So it's the role of Architect.

      • What challenges or organisational barriers might prevent leaders from moving from managing day-to-day execution to leading "above the loop"?

      Leaders with trust issues, micromanagement habit and the habit of knowledge hoarding would face issues - those kind of leaders aren't used to be staying above the loop.  

      • How can leaders encourage AI-driven innovation while ensuring accountability, governance and employee trust are maintained?

      By creating an environment where there is freedom of failure allowed along side clear goals and outcome with tighter governance and knowledge sharing culture. 

      Reply to Comment
      Cancel
      • Collapse Subdiscussion Edoardo Bertolani

        I believe the Architect requires the greatest transformation. In banking, governance and risk controls are already strong, but AI is still often added to existing processes rather than used to redesign them.

        The biggest barrier to leading “above the loop” is that managers are accustomed to supervising tasks and approving decisions. As AI becomes more autonomous, leadership should shift towards designing systems, setting objectives and defining boundaries.

        Accountability should not necessarily mean humans approving every AI decision. AI could operate autonomously within clear guardrails, with humans intervening mainly when exceptions or red flags arise. This is closer to genuinely leading “above the loop.”

        Reply to Comment
        Cancel
        • Collapse Subdiscussion Jennifer Tan

          In my organization—an agricultural science MNC—the role that requires the greatest transformation is the leaders. The agriculture industry is deeply rooted in tradition, with a strong cultural appreciation for tangible, manual work—essentially, "what hands can do." Because many of our leaders are industry veterans, their current management style is heavily tied to these traditional methods.

          The challenge is shifting these leaders away from managing via legacy Excel sheets and manual processes. It will require extensive change management to help them embrace their role as digital orchestrators—adapting to new technologies, trusting automated insights, and seamlessly coordinating these new tools across the business

          For question 3, believe striking the right balance comes down to a mix of active executive leadership, clear guardrails, and genuine workforce empowerment. First, top leaders have to show real buy-in and lead by example—not just giving lip service to AI, but actively modeling its use and driving cross-functional collaboration between IT, R&D, legal, and field operations. To keep innovation accountable, leadership must set explicit guidelines.  Finally, maintaining employee trust requires total transparency about how AI is meant to complement human expertise—not replace it—backed up by a real commitment to reskilling and training our people so they feel confident growing alongside the technology.

          Edited by Jennifer Tan on Oct 12 at 10:55am
          Reply to Comment
          Cancel
          • Collapse Subdiscussion Mark Jefferson Go

            Which of the three leadership roles—Orchestrator, Architect or Steward—do you believe requires the greatest transformation in your organisation? Explain your reasoning using examples where appropriate.

            • I think it's the Architect role. With respect to technology, the current way of doing it in our organization is to bolt it in as a tool. But Agentic AI is not just a tool to use, but a partner that changes the way we execute workflows

             

            What challenges or organisational barriers might prevent leaders from moving from managing day-to-day execution to leading "above the loop"?

            - Lack of trust in the people to execute the new hybrid workflow (humans +.AI). People in the organization are generally skeptical of any major change, esp the more tenured ones.

             

            How can leaders encourage AI-driven innovation while ensuring accountability, governance and employee trust are maintained?

            - I think it is by really involving the people to co-create the new workflow. This is to drive ownership and accountability 

            Reply to Comment
            Cancel
            • Collapse Subdiscussion Nora Pataut

              1) From a Pharma context, I think the Orchestrator is the role that requires the most work in the redesigned AI workflow, but Steward are the least prepared and would require extensive training catch-up on risk and governance.

              The Architect's Role: The architect can no longer just design a cleanroom layout or select stainless steel vs. single-use bioreactors. They must design an integrated cyber-physical system where hardware, software, and data flow seamlessly, ensuring data integrity (ALCOA+ principles) while remaining flexible enough to adapt to novel modalities (e.g., mRNA, viral vectors, ADCs).

              2) Leading "above the loop" means moving away from micro-monitoring of process execution ("in the loop") or automated exception handling ("on the loop") toward system design, strategic oversight, capability building, and governance.

              The challenges are related to risk aversion and regulatory fear. For example, deviations from standard operating procedures (SOPs) can lead to lost batches costing millions of dollars or regulatory warning letters. So leaders are culturally conditioned to stay "in the loop"—personally verifying batch records, signing off on minor deviations, and micromanaging daily operations, out of fear that delegating to automated or AI systems introduces unquantifiable regulatory risk.

              3) The development of a sustainable framework to support "in-the-loop" and "above-the-loop" and their interdependencies will be necessary to successfully achieve AI-driven innovation. For example, the Quality Assurance lead remains legally accountable for product release, while AI provides continuous risk scoring and anomaly detection to inform those decisions. Overall, it is about anchoring digital tools in validated Quality-by-Design frameworks while keeping human expertise at the centre of quality decisions.

               

              Reply to Comment
              Cancel