Press ALT + F8 to see a list of keyboard shortcuts

Discussion board 12.3: Think & share šŸ’”Leading Human–AI Teams: Where Should Human Judgment Prevail?

All Sections
3 unread replies. 3 replies.
  1.  Module 12: Introduction and Instructions (Completed)
  2.  Video 1 [03:27]: Module Introduction (Completed)
  3.  Video 2 [04:22]: The Leadership Bottleneck (Completed)
  4.  Video 3 [04:10]: How the Bottleneck Shows Up in Practice (Completed)
  5.  Self-Study Quiz 12.1šŸ’”Think & Apply: From Intelligence to Leadership: Navigating the Leadership Bottleneck ((Must submit the Quiz))
  6.  Video 4 [02:47]: The Leadership Framework for the AI Era (Completed)
  7.  Video 5 [03:32]: Applying WHY–WHAT–HOW to Real Decisions (Completed)
  8.  Video 6 [03:38]: Common Mistakes in Using the Framework (Completed)
  9.  Video 7 [01:11]: Human Judgement in AI Era (Completed)
  10.  Self-Study Quiz 12.2šŸ’”Think & Apply: Leading with Purpose: Applying the WHY–WHAT–HOW Framework ((Must submit the Quiz))
  11.  Video 8 [05:18]: What is High-Quality Judgment? (Completed)
  12.  Video 9 [02:12]: Leadership in the AI Era (Completed)
  13.  Discussion board 12.3: Think & share šŸ’”Leading Human–AI Teams: Where Should Human Judgment Prevail? ((Not yet completed))
  14.  Video 10 [03:40]: Final Thoughts ((Must view in order to complete this module item))
  15.  Self-Study Assignment 12.4: Think & ActšŸ’”Leading Beyond the Bottleneck: Redefining Leadership in the AI Era ((Must view in order to complete this module item))
  16.  Reading: Leading Through the Irreversible Shift ((Must view in order to complete this module item))
  17.  Self-Study Assignment 12.5: Think & ActšŸ’”Designing an AI-First Leadership Strategy ((Must view in order to complete this module item))
  18.  Summary and Video Transcripts: Module 12⭐ ((Must view in order to complete this module item))
  19.  Professor Alvin's Recommendation for Further Learning: Module 12 ((Must view in order to complete this module item))
  20.  Module 12: Q&A Discussion Board ((Not yet completed))
  21.  Module 12: Feedback Survey ((Must submit the Quiz))

Module Outcomes.pngLearning Outcomes Addressed: 

  • Apply the WHY–WHAT–HOW framework to frame problems and guide AI-supported decision-making.
  • Recognise how increased decision and learning velocity reveals leadership capability within organisations.

Scenario

Imagine that your organisation announces that 30% of your workforce will consist of AI agents capable of analysing information, generating recommendations and executing routine operational tasks.

As a senior leader, you are responsible for ensuring that AI enhances organisational performance while maintaining strategic alignment, accountability, and effective decision-making.

Drawing on the concepts from this module, addressing the following:

  • Leadership Responsibilities: Which of your current leadership responsibilities would change the most in this new environment? Explain your reasoning.
  • Human Judgement: Identify one area where human judgement should remain non-negotiable, even if AI can provide faster or more accurate analysis. Justify your response.
  • Leadership Capability: Which leadership capability will become most critical for leaders over the next five years? Explain how it will help organisations succeed in an AI-enabled environment.
  • Decision-Making: Describe one practical change you would make to your team's decision-making process to ensure AI improves organisational alignment rather than increasing complexity. 

Support your response with concepts and frameworks presented in this module.

Peer Engagement

After posting your response, review the contributions of at least one peer and provide a constructive response that:

  • Identifies one insight or recommendation you found particularly valuable.
  • Suggests one additional leadership capability, governance consideration, or decision-making practice that could strengthen their approach.
  • Explains why your recommendation would improve leadership effectiveness in an AI-enabled organisation.

We also encourage you to go through your peers' responses and share your views.

Estimated Duration: 20-25 minutes

NOTE: This is a practice activity and will not be graded or impact your programme completion. However, we strongly encourage participation for a more holistic learning experience.

Filter replies by unread    
Reply to Discussion board 12.3: Think & share šŸ’”Leading Human–AI Teams: Where Should Human Judgment Prevail?
Cancel
  • Collapse Subdiscussion Priya Jha
    • Leadership Responsibilities: Which of your current leadership responsibilities would change the most in this new environment? Explain your reasoning.

    I will start with WHY: what are we trying to achieve and why does it matter? Understanding the problem clearly and is the problem worth solving ? Then WHAT: what outcome do we need? Does it align well with our Organizational Objectives. Only then would I look at HOW AI agents, people and processes should work together to deliver it

    • Human Judgement: Identify one area where human judgement should remain non-negotiable, even if AI can provide faster or more accurate analysis. Justify your response.

    Decisions that impacts Organizations reputation or finance should remain non-negotiable. 

    • Leadership Capability: Which leadership capability will become most critical for leaders over the next five years? Explain how it will help organisations succeed in an AI-enabled environment.

    Problem framing and judgement. To decide what problems are worth solving, what tradeoffs are worth taking and what options align with Organizational goals

    • Decision-Making: Describe one practical change you would make to your team's decision-making process to ensure AI improves organisational alignment rather than increasing complexity. 

    Introduce AI augmented decision records. After WHY and WHAT is decided, AI will be used for options analysis and providing recommendations and human would take the final decision

    Reply to Comment
    Cancel
    • Collapse Subdiscussion Hadrian

      The biggest changes on leadership responsibilities is about orchestrating the rest 70% human in the team with 30% AI agent, i.e.

      • All works should be aligned and deliver the business performance, that will be demonstrated by business performance metrics
      • Built the workflow to ensure all team able to work in collaboration with AI agents
      • Define and agree the priorities with the team, while reviewing with confident judgement for any outcomes from all AI agents

      Human judgement will remain keys to build the context into all decision and prioritization. It is also useful to ensure recommendations from the analysis will still within the guardrail of achieving long term vision of the organization, esp. long term impact post executing the recommendations.

      Practical approach on decision making:

      • Before the works: define and agree on the context, the purpose of the works and what will success looks like (including impact to business)
      • During the works: agile approach to let check in in the middle of process, including sharpening and reshaping by training the AI agents
      • After the works: before taking the decision, always go back to purpose, success look like for each options coming the AI analysis
      Reply to Comment
      Cancel
      • Collapse Subdiscussion Edoardo Bertolani
        • My role would shift most from supervising execution to defining direction and designing the decision system. If AI agents perform much of the analysis and execution, leadership should increasingly own the Why and What, while AI handles much of the How.
        • Today, I would keep human judgement non-negotiable for decisions involving fundamental values, accountability and acceptable risk. However, I would challenge whether this must remain true forever. If AI eventually becomes demonstrably better than humans at evaluating evidence, context and consequences, mandatory human approval could itself become a source of error or delay. What should remain non-negotiable may ultimately be accountability, validation and escalation when AI detects uncertainty, inconsistency or value conflicts, rather
        • The most important capability will therefore be problem framing and system design: defining objectives, constraints, decision rights and escalation mechanisms. Leaders increasingly become Architects, Orchestrators and Stewards of human–AI systems rather than simply managers of people.
        • I would institutionalise WHY / WHAT / HOW for significant decisions: first agree on the purpose and desired impact; then define the actual problem and success criteria; only then use AI to determine or recommend how to achieve it. This prevents faster AI execution from simply producing faster misalignment.
        Reply to Comment (1 like)
        Cancel